Phil has a monumental comment here where he lists top five albums by genre. Now, while i still think that idea is totally cool, it also call to attention the fun, instructive, and often useless practice of labeling…sometimes, it is hard to agree on what constitutes ANY genre of anything, but we have to put everything somewhere.
In academia, we do this most egregiously with the phrase 20th century music, which would be fine if Glass, Schoenberg, Proto, Shostakovich, Cage, and Williams had anything in common other than the fact they were all composers. I also notice they are all men…I admit, I don’t know many female composers (I can name more than the obligatory Barbara Strozzi, Amy Beach, Clara Schumann, and Fanny Mendelssohn, though). In fact, once you stop thinking of music as anything OTHER than music, your ipod seems less, well, random. At least mine did.
All this calls to mind my favorite movie quote, and one of the most disturbing moments I’ve had at the movies: the part in the Dark Knight where the Joker starts making sense. He’s talking to Harvey Dent in the hospital, and says “You know what I’ve noticed? Nobody panics when things go “according to plan.” Even if the plan is horrifying! If, tomorrow, I tell the press that, like, a gang banger will get shot, or a truckload of soldiers will be blown up, nobody panics, because it’s all “part of the plan.” But when I say that one little old mayor will die, well then everyone loses their minds!”
Lists are, well, part of the plan. An attempt to see patterns in the chaos. I find the human ability to see connections from complete random chaos fascinating (like the Michael Jackson “7″ article I read today). So, I’m going to attempt a Top Five Random Album List That I See A Common Thread With, but not today. Today, I’m going to list
Top Five Albums on our iTunes that I don’t really like, but don’t want to get rid of.
- Franck, Symphony in d minor, Berlin Philharmonic with Lorin Maazel
- Dave Holland and Barre Phillips, Music for Two Basses (you have no idea how guilty I feel listing that one)
- Evanescence, Fallen
- Korn, Greatest Hits, Vol. 1
- Nine Inch Nails, With Teeth.
Of the list, the only one that I’d be happy to purge my collection of is the Evanescence. The Korn is all you need to know about nu-metal in one handy package, the duo album still hasn’t grown on me, I’ve never cared for Franck, but never really studied his music either, and the NIN is simply ok.
Anything you all want to share that you’re happy you have, but somehow, it never finds its way into your play lists?